Scottsdale Criminal Defense Lawyers
Criminal Defense Home Abour Our Firm Criminal Defense Attorney Profile Testimonials Criminal Defense Case Evaluation Contact a professional Criminal Defense lawyer.
Click here to be automatically connected to our law firm.
Click here to view our criminal defense blog
Practice Areas
Assault
Bench Warrants
Disorderly Conduct
Domestic Violence & Family Law
DUI Defense
Drug Charges
Federal Crimes
Fraud Crimes
Gang Related Offenses
Juvenile
Probation Violations
Resisting Arrest
Restraining Orders
Sex Crimes
Suspended License
Theft Crimes
Violent Crimes
Weapons Charges
9449 N 90th Street, Suite 207 Scottsdale, Arizona 85258
Case Results
News

Update in judicial discretion

Recently in US vs. Fernandes, No. 09-30135 (3-14-11)(Per curiam with Thomas, Graber, and Tallman) the question arose whether a court must order a defendant convicted of abusive sexual contact under 18 USC 2244(b) to register as a sex offender?  The defendant here worked as a security officer at a national park when he fondled and groped an intoxicated female employee in her room without her permission.  The court sentenced the defendant to probation, but refused to require registration.  The court explained/felt that there was no need for registration as the defendant had no priors, and would be unlikely to repeat such an offense.  It doesn't matter, explains the 9th, which reverses and amends with instructions to put registration as a condition.

Under the statutes, the defendant was convicted of a sexual offense, he is defined as a sexual offender, and so he must register.  There is no discretion afforded.  The defendant's arguments about discretion under Booker and parsimony do not trump a congressional mandate.  The constitutional challenge is also denied.

Law Offices of Randal J. Craig Scottsdale Premier Criminal Defense Firm
Click here to be automatically connected to our law office. Criminal Defense Firm in Scottsdale Violent Crimes Attorneys

Scottsdale Criminal Defense Attorney | Contact Us | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Defense Resources

Attorney Web Design The information on this Scottsdale website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information on this website is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing of this information does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.

Address: 9449 N 90th Street, Suite 207 Scottsdale, AZ 85258 Phone: (888) 402-7004